MercoPress, en Español

Montevideo, April 18th 2024 - 07:01 UTC

 

 

In Brazilian school books Columbus arrived in America in 1942

Sunday, April 5th 2009 - 06:20 UTC
Full article 1 comment
A portrait of Christopher Columbus A portrait of Christopher Columbus

Christopher Columbus must be having nightmares: according to the Brazilian state of Sao Paulo latest edition of public school books, the Genoa navigator arrived to America in 1942, that is 67 years ago and not in 1492.

The error comes a few days after a previous exposure of geographic distortions in the Sao Paulo books for the state run school system, which ended with the sacking of the Education minister.

Philosophy professor Claudio Da Silva and Sao Paulo teachers union leader claims there’s a “moral crisis” in the education system of Brazil’s richest and most populated state.

“Book contents were rushed, copying them from internet with no further checking or supervision. We’ve come across gross mistakes in geography, history and even the Portuguese language orthography and syntax”, underlined the teacher.

In the latest edition of history books for primary schools Christopher Columbus arrived in America in 1942, not 1492, a mistake the state government attributed to poor “typing” and therefore will not replace the editions already distributed among school children.

The O Estado de Sao Paulo also published Brazilian geography mistakes such as the river Xingu, in the Amazon, but which for some miraculous reason moved to the southern state of Rio Grande do Sul, neighbouring with Argentina and Uruguay.

Another mishap refers to the history of the Palo-Brazil tree (pau Brazil) which is said to be originated in the Amazon rain forest, when it actually belonged to Brazilian coastal areas.

The Vanzolini foundation and the state of Sao Paulo which contracted them to publish the books two weeks ago were accused of disregarding quality education by distributing another school book with a map of South America which had countries changed.

Ecuador did not figure and Paraguay figured twice, instead of Uruguay (coastal) and as a province of Bolivia. Landlocked Paraguay is replaced by Uruguay.

Sao Paulo authorities sacked the Education Secretary and promised a corrected reprint of the 150.000 school books for mid April.

Top Comments

Disclaimer & comment rules
  • Karina Santos

    I'm a brazilian student, and I know the right is 1492... We have good maps, without mistakes.... The people think that we are animals... Gosh...

    Apr 07th, 2009 - 01:26 am 0
Read all comments

Commenting for this story is now closed.
If you have a Facebook account, become a fan and comment on our Facebook Page!