MercoPress, en Español

Montevideo, January 17th 2019 - 05:48 UTC

“Humanitarian approach”, the new Falklands' policy of the Macri administration

Thursday, May 19th 2016 - 07:12 UTC
Full article 60 comments
The column of Matin Dinatale, published in La Nacion displays the new policy under the heading ”Malvinas: Macri's approachment plan The column of Matin Dinatale, published in La Nacion displays the new policy under the heading ”Malvinas: Macri's approachment plan
However it is a path which has its risks, it simply can't be compared to Menem and Di Tella's Winnie the Pooh friendly policy of the nineties which led nowhere However it is a path which has its risks, it simply can't be compared to Menem and Di Tella's Winnie the Pooh friendly policy of the nineties which led nowhere
Malcorra who is linked to the idea of the humanitarian approach, as a professional engineer looks at the issue based on the Paretto principle Malcorra who is linked to the idea of the humanitarian approach, as a professional engineer looks at the issue based on the Paretto principle
Dinatale reveals Malcorra recently offered that sanitary emergencies in the Falklands be treated in Argentina, instead of going to London or Punta Arenas Dinatale reveals Malcorra recently offered that sanitary emergencies in the Falklands be treated in Argentina, instead of going to London or Punta Arenas
Another step is “an open doors trade policy”, which could mean fresh food, fruit and vegetables. Another step is “an open doors trade policy”, which could mean fresh food, fruit and vegetables.

“Humanitarian approach” is how Argentine diplomacy plans to implement policy towards the Falkland Islands including greater air and sea contacts, which could lead to open trade, convincing Mercosur members to lift the ban, plus offers of specialized medicine and higher education opportunities for Falkland Islanders.

 That is what the column of Matin Dinatale, published in La Nacion displays under the heading “Malvinas: Macri's approachment plan”, which has the long term purpose of claiming sovereignty over the Falklands. In effect once the first steps are consolidated, there is even a chance of sharing oil and maritime deals, writes Dinatale who usually has solid reliable information from Argentina's diplomatic moves and plans.

However it is a path which has its risks, it simply can't be compared to Menem and Di Tella's Winnie the Pooh friendly policy of the nineties which led nowhere, explains Dinatale.

Foreign minister Susana Malcorra who is linked to the idea of the humanitarian approach, as a professional engineer looks at the issue based on the Paretto principle: the Macri administration is aware that in the agenda with UK there's an 80% agreement, and 20% disagreement. “The advantage is that with the UK we know that Malvinas represent the 20%, so instead of dedicating all our time to that 20%, we are not going to work for results in the 80%”.

Will this mean dropping Falklands' sovereignty claim, not at all. The way is to work with UK in what the foreign office calls the “new positive agenda” and in line with what ambassador in Buenos Aires, John Freeman said recently, “UK wishes to return to the historic friendly relation with Argentina; sealing trade, science, technology and infrastructure accords.

Likewise parallel to London-Buenos Aires dialogue, Malcorra is prepared to rebuild relations with the Islanders, since ”now there's a greater acknowledgement to the participation of the civil society in different ways“, or in other words ”opening options“ and a more flexible diplomacy.

Dinatale then reveals that Malcorra recently offered that sanitary emergencies in the Falklands be treated in Argentina, so that complex surgeries patients don't need to travel to London or the Punta Arenas hospital.

Another step is ”an open doors trade policy“, which could mean fresh food, fruit and vegetables. Later on, the possibility of sharing oil and maritime businesses between Falkland Islanders and Argentines.

But this scenario is considered in a particular interpretation of international events: the recent UN announcement extending Argentina's maritime continental shelf, beyond the Falklands, and the coming Brexit referendum next June, when UK could decide to leave the European Union.

According to these interpretations, Argentina could potentially in a near future begin exploratory drilling in waters close to the Falklands, ”and Islanders know this and admit it is an irreversible situation”. As to the EU referendum, Falklands admit its impact if UK decides to leave, (as such it was reported to Parliament) and several countries in the continent would no longer feel obliged to support the British position on the Malvinas, including obviously Spain.

But Dinatale also underlines that the “humanitarian approach” to be launched very soon is a long term policy with results not necessarily expected to be achieved and enjoyed by the current Argentine government. It's a long sinuous path, and the success of this strategy, as German political scientist points out Wolf Grandendorff rests on avoiding implementing a policy of “exaggerated expectations”, since abrupt turns and pendulum changes usually lead to failure.

Top Comments

Disclaimer & comment rules
  • Skip

    This article is all over the place. It jumps from topic to topic in the hope it can tie them all together.

    It didn't.

    And it can't.

    Closer relations can happen. Doesn't mean there will be a 'reward' for Argentina.

    May 19th, 2016 - 08:13 am 0
  • Conqueror

    A repeat of the 90s. At least, this time, argieland admits that its final objective is sovereignty. Islanders must make up their own minds. But, for the benefit of young Islanders, I'd just like to mention a few pertinent factors. In 1982, 775 British servicemen were wounded and another 255 were killed retaking your Islands so that you could have the freedom you currently enjoy. Britain has spent and continues to spend billions on your infrastructure and protection. Argieland is broke. It will take your land, your resources and your freedom. Remember that, in '82, argieland made various promises to convince the world that it was liberating you. It wasn't long before you were forced to drive on the right, learn and speak spanish and accept argie currency as worth something. Look at the history of argieland since the 70s. How do you see your chances of being accorded any degree of respect or autonomy? According to argies, you are already a part of a province. Whereas, for the most part, Britain treats you as a country in formation. Do you look forward to getting your argie ID and passport? Travelling, perhaps to Britain, and encountering the possibility of contempt. Thirty-plus years and Britain still stands by you. You are not a useful military base now in the 21st century. Your gas and oil resources are your own. Britain is already committed to that. Argieland will simply take those resources.

    So be very careful with argieland's charm offensive. Remember that, for more than 80 years, argies have considered you to be bandits, interlopers, pirates. Will that change overnight or will you have to prove that you can be “good” argies?

    Take what you can, but always remember who your true friends are!

    May 19th, 2016 - 08:28 am 0
  • The Voice

    Remember, Choripans are the currency of bribery and corruption in the dark country… What are they actually worth? Think about it..

    May 19th, 2016 - 08:35 am 0
Read all comments

Commenting for this story is now closed.
If you have a Facebook account, become a fan and comment on our Facebook Page!