MercoPress, en Español

Montevideo, August 17th 2017 - 05:55 UTC

Falklands war new book says invading Argentines faced fierce defense from Marines and suffered heavy casualties

Monday, July 24th 2017 - 06:09 UTC
Full article 211 comments
The First Casualty was written after Ricky Phillips interviewed survivors on both sides to get the full story. The First Casualty was written after Ricky Phillips interviewed survivors on both sides to get the full story.
Philips findings contradict the story told at the time that the Argentines caught the garrison napping, and also call into question the official history of the conflict. Philips findings contradict the story told at the time that the Argentines caught the garrison napping, and also call into question the official history of the conflict.
It has long been rumored that the garrison of marines mounted a strong defense before Sir Rex Hunt ordered the surrender to save the civilian population  It has long been rumored that the garrison of marines mounted a strong defense before Sir Rex Hunt ordered the surrender to save the civilian population

A new book has challenged the official account of the Falklands War, including allegedly one of the worst kept secrets of the conflict. The First Casualty, written by noted military historian Ricky Phillips, reveals that, far from surrendering without a fight when the Argentines invaded the Islands in April 1982, a detachment of Royal Marines battled for more than two hours and killed around 100 of their opponents.

 It has long been rumored that the garrison of marines near Stanley mounted a strong defense before Governor Sir Rex Hunt ordered the surrender to save the civilian population three hours after the Argentines landed.

A top Scottish academic has greeted the new book as “important”.

Tony Pollard, a professor of conflict history at Glasgow University and an expert on the Falklands, welcomed the publication on Sunday. He said: “This book succeeds in being an important work as it tells for the first time the full story of the fight to defend the Islands.

“There are numerous books on the Falklands War, but most reduce this vital episode down to a few paragraphs before moving on to the better-known battles following the landing of the British task force.”

The First Casualty was written after Phillips interviewed survivors on both sides to get the full story. His findings contradict the story told at the time, that the Argentines caught the garrison napping, and also call into question the official history of the conflict.

The book details the initial landing and confrontation, and contains eyewitness testimonies of many more deaths and injuries than was admitted to at the time.

Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher did not want to detract from the “Argentine aggression” story, while the government of General Fortunato Galtieri did not want their heavy casualties revealed. In his blog, Ricky Phillips detailed how participants in the battle contacted him to tell their stories.

He said: “Working with the men of the Royal Marines Naval Party 8901 who defended Stanley on that day, I began to gather interviews. Many wrote down their experiences, there were emails, private messages, hundreds of phone calls, hand-drawn maps, every piece of information fitted into a collage which told a different story — and many of these guys haven’t spoken for over thirty years.

“Then came the people of Stanley who were there that night and now we got interesting; personal accounts, private diaries from the invasion, photograph... more than has ever been said about this.

“But then came the real shocker — the Argentines turned up. They weren’t happy with this story of a mere ‘token defense’ or walk-over.

Accordingly a band of 60 Royal Marines fought a three-hour battle, killing as many Argentines without a single casualty. They fired 6,462 rounds before Governor Rex Hunt demanded a ceasefire to save islanders.

Author Ricky D Phillips argues that “When a brave man says with tears in his eyes you’ve given him his dignity back, you know you’ve done the right thing”

Top Comments

Disclaimer & comment rules
  • Roger Lorton

    British pluck

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tNk4SMN6t3A

    Jul 24th, 2017 - 07:20 am +8
  • RickyDPhillips

    Despite the serial liar and internet troll Tomas Morando trolling the conversation thread - nothing new there from those that know this lunatic - the only person worth answering is “Islander1”. As a Falkland Islander you will know exactly...sadly, as I have found out, the “Oh well, WE know and that's what's important” idea is limited to 3,000 Falkland Islanders. Nobody else knows! This is the book of the Royal Marines BY the Royal Marines and it tels everyone else. I'm glad you know but trust me, this isn't the first time...it isn't even the 100th time I've had this conversation...NOBODY ELSE KNOWS!
    Now, if you ask those amazing men who fought to defend your country on April 2nd, to a man they will back me on their own story...I'm very far from stupid. Indeed I'm the first person in 35 years to ever question what he rest of the world was told.

    Jul 24th, 2017 - 07:32 pm +7
  • Stoker

    Here's just one of the many reasons defence was - and is - necessary
    http://www.southwalesargus.co.uk/news/8410550.Friendship_forged_in_Falklands_War_endures_for_Newport_man/
    I wonder if the Argies have been toilet trained yet? ;-D

    Jul 24th, 2017 - 07:22 am +6
Read all comments

Commenting for this story is now closed.
If you have a Facebook account, become a fan and comment on our Facebook Page!