MercoPress, en Español

Montevideo, October 19th 2018 - 03:06 UTC

Conditions in Venezuelan prisons are “beyond monstrous” claims UN human rights office

Thursday, October 11th 2018 - 08:58 UTC
Full article 27 comments

Conditions in Venezuela’s prisons are “beyond monstrous”, the UN human rights office, OHCHR, said, before calling for an independent and transparent investigation into the death of a leading political opponent of the Government. Issuing the alert in Geneva, OHCHR spokesperson Ravina Shamdasani said that there were specific concerns for the well-being of 59 Colombian nationals, who’ve been held for more than two years without being charged. Read full article

Comments

Disclaimer & comment rules
  • Patrick Edgar

    Now explain this to me;
    If this IS NOT a British interest political propaganda to do with undermining any South American government that would not be friendly or oppose the expansionist usurpation policy of Britain through the human shield that the Falkland Islands are, against Argentina's rightful claim to these islands, and all it supposedly seeks is economic area journalism ridding on the unrequited coat tails of Mercosur (as it is not actually part of Mercosur) ...what the h**l does it care what is happening in Venezuelan prisons?

    Oct 11th, 2018 - 01:10 pm - Link - Report abuse 0
  • Chicureo

    Patrick Edgar

    Welcome back! Unlike yourself, Terrence Hill and Enrique Massot have lacked the rich intellectual content contributions to this news site that covers many subjects throughout the Americas. (Especially Terrence needs a lot of support.)

    came to power, people cheered because he was going to help the poor and make everyone equal. But governments can't plan things efficiently without the prices and constant individual decision-making that free markets provide. The result in Cuba was economic stagnation and horrible loss of freedom.

    Venezuela voted in Hugo Chavez when he said that “capitalism is the realm of injustice” and promised wealth would be distributed equally. When he came to power, people cheered because he was going to help the poor and make everyone equal. The country he took over has the largest petroleum reserves in the world yet his country's oil production fell over 60%. But when there was no more money left to take from his own state owned petroleum company, he did what many governments do: He printed more. That's caused inflation over 1 million percent. When business owners raised prices to try to keep up, Chavez and his successor Maduro just seized many of them. People now wait in long lines to buy a scarce small bag of rice or rare roll of toilet paper. Now many people are very unhappy. An astounding amount of people have fled the country due to the economic collapse. Some countrymen have proposed an overthrow of the government and Maduro has been less than friendly to his opposition...

    Again, welcome back

    Oct 11th, 2018 - 02:08 pm - Link - Report abuse +1
  • Jack Bauer

    PE,
    Of course, “undermining” a South American government, that is a model of democracy for the world to copy....If I were you, I'd get on a plane and take advantage of this wonderful democracy before some foreign power conspires to turn it into a socialist, populist and authoritarian regime...forcing 100s of thousands of venezuelans to flee to neighbouring Colombia and Brazil...that WOULD be nasty...

    Oct 11th, 2018 - 07:30 pm - Link - Report abuse 0
  • DemonTree

    @PE
    Believe it or not, UK foreign policy doesn't revolve around the Falklands. Maduro is anti-capitalist and anti-business, so naturally the UK government would like to see him gone. Plus there's the whole human rights thing.

    If the Falklands are a human shield, what are they shielding?

    Posted 6 days ago - Link - Report abuse 0
  • Jack Bauer

    @DT (cont. of “Chile can't be forced...”

    Lying ? don’t think so...just that when his expectations dwindled, thought the best chance of survival was Haddad.

    Suffices for Maduro, like in the USSR, to declare his adversaries enemies of the State, accuse them falsely ‘n jail them. Thought you’d realized by now that the chance of being put on trial in VZ is non-existent. Maduro decides his opponents’ fates.

    If you can, give up doubting why Lula is in jail...I’ve posted enough, showing where the evidence is, ‘n I am not about to start another round of unproductive discussions.

    Here, the MST ‘n other lefties have incited violence, destroyed farms…None are in jail. If the PT didn’t sympathize with Maduro, why openly support him ? because they like his govt.

    “it’s democracy as long as it works for them”…inevitable conclusion after seeing what they have fits over…Exs: one, FHC ‘bolsas’: hypocritical, until the PT expanded them to become the BF; two, it was anti-democratic (by Temer) to stop teaching gender-identity to young children; three, ok to try to impeach FHC, but called Dilma’s impeachemt anti-democratic.

    Brazil & US, despite roughly same age, were colonized by different ‘powers’, with totally different intentions…’n are in very different stages of social progress (altho are both experimenting social turbulence), that’s why Brazil is not ready for what works in the US.

    I never said you’d “agree” with me (100%) IF you lived in Bzl…implied you’d be aware how things work, ‘n might see it differently to how you see it now.

    Not on me “personally”, but on society - don’t take everything I say so ‘literally’.

    If you don’t believe what the PT’s capable of - you obviously believe they had nothing to do with the 3 mayors’ ('n witnesses) assassinations, that they didn’t buy the police to play along - no point discussing ‘this’ further.

    Threat of nuclear war in Bzl, no, but of a communist takeover, yes. You saw the CW ‘end’, when it was already fading out.

    Posted 6 days ago - Link - Report abuse 0
  • DemonTree

    “Thought you’d realized by now...”

    That's not my opinion, I was repeating what Think said. LL did have a trial - it was dodgy as hell, but he had one. So I suppose people who believe he and the others are guilty anyway can decide there is no problem and Vz is not a dictatorship... I dunno. And I didn't mean to reopen any question about Lula, don't worry about that.

    Do you know if the PSDB voted in favour of the BF, since it was based on a program they started? And why did the PT want to impeach FHC? Teaching gender-identity?

    “Brazil is not ready for what works in the US”

    That's what I thought. But then surely the US should be able to afford a health care system of some sort that covers everyone, like European countries? And how come Brazil can afford to provide free university education, even to non-citizens, while in the US (and UK) you must pay?

    ”I never said you’d “agree” with me (100%) IF you lived in Bzl“

    Well sure I'd see things differently, but you also implied I wouldn't be a liberal, which I think is highly unlikely. I'm sure if you were born and brought up in the UK you'd still be conservative, though you wouldn't be A-OK with death squads, I hope.

    Speaking of which, random question: what accent do you have? British, American, something else?

    ”Not on me “personally”“

    So the dreaded 'minorities' haven't actually imposed anything on you? I just want an example so I know what it is you object to.

    ”you obviously believe they had nothing to do with the 3 mayors’ assassinations“

    I'm not going to believe it without seeing any evidence, or even knowing the facts, no. That doesn't mean I'm sure it wasn't the PT; I doubt there is enough evidence for more than a suspicion, but I could be wrong.

    ”Threat of nuclear war in Bzl, no, but of a communist takeover, yes.”

    Better dead than red? But yes, I only saw the end. After that we had the Gulf War, then Yugoslavia, then Afghanistan, then Iraq, Libya, Syria... are things better now?

    Posted 6 days ago - Link - Report abuse 0
  • Jack Bauer

    “..what Think said”…OK. VZ trials are for show, not serious.

    Re BF, searched but unable find specifics how parties voted in 2013, but I’m prepared to believe parts of the PSDB voted against it - perhaps they thought the PT was usurping their initiative ? However, 2013, PSDB, in an attempt to de-politicize the BF, proposed extending it 6 months after getting a job, to allow them to settle in…another, transform BF into State Policy (gteed by Nat’l Fund for Social Assistance), I/O being ‘govt’ or ‘party’ policy’ …PT voted against both projects. Btwn ‘95/03, PT tried to impeach FHC 4 times. Accusations go fm corruption to electoral fraud. Congress found nothing to back them up.

    The PT introduced gender-ideology in schools for children – it’s not important how you’re born, yr acts define you – eventually true, but hardly a subject for children (deconstruction of trad’l family values ?); parents got furious. If when older, you want to switch sides, be my guest.

    US health system – to start with, the US has 4 times the population of Germany, ‘n 10, 20, 30 times of many others, so in EU it’s obviously easier, and by what I heard, but can’t remember why, medical costs in the US are much higher.

    If you lived in Brazil, I don’t know what you’d be, but try imagining yourself brought up in a country that is neither organized, nor knows what 'tested', moderate socialism is, as in EU.

    Although personality is innate, IMO your views/attitudes are molded by your surroundings.
    In the US people say my accent is British, in Britain they get confused.

    Ex: gender-less bathrooms, special laws to give those who declare themselves other than male/female, privileges others don’t have.

    It’s far too complicated/extensive to even try to explain circumstances of (what I ‘n millions believe were) PT assassinations. But let’s forget it, you think PT is saintly.

    The wars you mention were/are regional. Better ? no, where did I imply that ?...and at least no nuclear threat.

    Posted 5 days ago - Link - Report abuse 0
  • DemonTree

    I looked up the attempt to impeach FHC, it said Lula did not support what his party was doing, because he was already becoming less radical and moving to be closer to business, and hoped to win at the polls instead. It also says they found out FHC received donations from banks for his campaign, but Paulo Okamoto told them they couldn't use it against him because they had also received donations from bankers. Seems some things never change.

    I don't understand what the difference is between state policy and govt policy?

    Re US health system, I don't think the size is an issue. Germany has no more problems than Belgium or other countries only a fraction of its size. I've heard a lot of reasons why medicine costs so much in America, but that would be a whole post in itself...

    “The PT introduced gender-ideology in schools”

    Do you mean they made it compulsory to teach it, or allowed schools to do so? And did Temer make it optional or ban it completely? I should think it might be useful to explain *if* the kids will be encountering a transexual person. In the UK, when I was at school there was a law called Section 28, which banned 'promoting homosexuality' and teaching 'the acceptability of homosexuality as a pretended family relationship'. It wasn't repealed until 2003, but I don't think it achieved what they hoped for.

    And what privileges do you get by declaring yourself other than male or female? I never heard of any.

    If I lived in Brazil I'd probably be a lot more radical because (AFAIK) there is more prejudice there. As for attitudes, the same view could be considered conservative in one country and liberal in another, so obviously surroundings make a big difference, but I think the tendency to be conservative or liberal is largely innate. Though education does seem to make people more liberal, maybe because it exposes you to lots of new ideas and people, making the strange become familiar.

    Run out of space again...

    Posted 5 days ago - Link - Report abuse 0
  • Voice

        
        
       

    Posted 4 days ago - Link - Report abuse 0
  • DemonTree

    Thanks, Voice.

    “you think PT is saintly”

    Because if I don't believe they're the devil incarnate, that's the only alternative? I think they're a political party that did some good things and some bad, and unfortunately got involved in corruption just like the others. Carrying out assassinations is a big step beyond that, so the evidence would have to be pretty convincing for me to believe it. If I claimed the Republican party had assassinated someone and hushed it up, what evidence would convince you?

    “where did I imply that ?”

    You didn't, I was just wondering. After the CW ended there was a lot of optimism and the world seemed to generally be getting richer, freer, and more democratic. But now with all this Islamic terrorism, the failure of America's attempt at 'nation building' in Iraq and most of the Arab Spring revolutions, and countries like China and Russia becoming more repressive again, it seems everything is going backwards.

    As for Putin, what makes you think he really believed in communism in the first place? I assume kids were indoctrinated at school, but people must have had some idea of what was going on outside the USSR, and how much richer and better off the capitalist West was.

    Posted 4 days ago - Link - Report abuse 0
  • Jack Bauer

    DT
    Just about every politician in this country is guilty of what Lula accused FHC…including Lula…the hypocrisy behind it was obvious, even Okamoto realized that...but, it was just the PT being itself.

    State policy : to make it law, I/O leaving it as a simple (government/party in power) policy, which could be discontinued at any time.

    Gender-ideology : yes, obligatory part of the curriculum...some teachers/schools objected, but nothing was done about it until Temer took a decision to stop it.
    Explaining to kids, ‘if ‘n when’ encountered, is one thing, another is to place doubts in kid’s minds as to what sex they really are. IMO, not the time, nor place to discuss it.

    One of Haddad’s proposals, going one further after the ‘quotas’ in universities : declare yourself a transvestite, or a transgender person, and gain the right to a scholarship. When will it stop ?

    I’m well aware that the same things can be seen differently in different countries, ‘n the way they are seen, presumably depends on the stage of social development/clarification.
    Of course education opens yr mind, but after being exposed to the 'new' ideas, it’s up to you to want to embrace them or not.

    “PT saintly” v. devil incarnate? of course not, but more times than not you defend them, question my experience with them as if invalid…I don’t like them, and it’s not gratuitous.

    Looks like you’re not familiar with political assassinations…they happen here quite a lot, but the 3 mentioned were very conspicuous, given the circumstances 'n especially the threats Celso Daniel’s brother received. Plus, the police dragged their feet…at a time justice was extremely inefficient.
    The defendant’s and the defense witnesses' accounts of what happened where contradictory, they claimed the car had a malfunction, proved by Mitsubishi to be a lie…and other things.
    Without a smoking gun, you gather up circumstancial evidence…'n believe it or not.

    Putin was the KGB in the USSR…not enough ?

    Need space...

    Posted 4 days ago - Link - Report abuse 0
  • Voice

      
       
       

    Posted 4 days ago - Link - Report abuse 0
  • DemonTree

    @Voice
    Thanks, and do feel free to weigh in if you want to.

    @JB
    “Temer took a decision to stop it”

    Did he just make it optional, or ban it like our Section 28? Kids may not understand the subject, but I doubt they'll get confused about something like that.

    “O Transcidadania garante bolsas de estudos para transgêneros em situação de vulnerabilidade social para que possam concluir o ensino médio e fundamental, articulado com a formação profissional.”

    “Ensino médio e fundamental” is school up to age 18? I wonder what situation of social vulnerability means? Thrown out by their parents onto the street, perhaps. Education is free in Brazil, so what does the scholarship pay for?

    “Just about every politician in this country is guilty of what Lula accused FHC”

    Yes, and according to the news just about every President was guilty of what Dilma was accused of, and the guy who allowed her impeachment is now in jail for corruption himself. It's hypocrisy all the way.

    “more times than not you defend them”

    I defended LL to Think, too. But I'm more inclined to sympathise with the PT because to some extent I share their aims (helping the poor, making Brazil more equal). Anyway, it's not like you believe everything I say about British politics; you told Conqueror you would have voted for Brexit.

    The only political assassination I've seen in Brazil was Marielle Franco's, and EM thinks Temer had something to do with that. Should I believe him without question, too?

    “Putin was the KGB in the USSR…not enough ?”

    Nope. Maybe he used to believe in it, maybe he was only ever there for personal power. There must have been a whole range of attitudes among KGB agents.

    Re views in different countries, it also depends on culture/religion, the latter being a big difference between the US and Europe, and Japan and China are vastly more different. And I think educated people are less likely to reject ideas simply for being unfamiliar, but to consider them seriously before deciding.

    Posted 4 days ago - Link - Report abuse 0
  • Jack Bauer

    DT
    Afaik, Temer banned it. Confused ? “later” on, expect not.
    Haddad’s proposal :“gtee scholarships, socially vulnerable trans-genders, so can finish fundamental/medium school, allied to professional qualification”. Fundamental : 6 -14, medium:15 -18 yrs;
    Social vulnerability ? perhaps what u suggest.
    Scholarships ? don’t know, as public schools ARE free, but his propaganda suggests for university matriculation…quotas ?

    “…accding to news just abt every Prez was guilty of what Dilma was accused of…” Technically yes, but w/ 3 distinctions : 1) amounts involved, peanuts compared to Dilma’s, 2) Congress authorized them, 3) accounts were back in the black by end of each fiscal year….very different to Dilma who obliged the fed bks to lend, w/o Congress’ approval, no register of loans by the bks, hide them, lie abt them ‘n the deficits, carry them over 2 years running…presume even you can tell the difference. Hypocrisy ? sure, but it’s the law.

    Sharing – to some extent – the PT’s ‘declared’ aims, quite natural…BUT, the PT did NOT deliver...14 years in power show that. The BF, while put enough food on the table, raised NO ONE “out-of-poverty”. Lula’s 18 Fed Univs, an enormous farce.

    By what I heard ‘here’, I’d have voted for Brexit…IF I lived in GB, would’ve been better informed/more interested, “may” have been against it, dunno.

    Re political assassinations, Marielle was just a high-profile one, becos : In Rio, fighting to improve conditions for the poor, being black. Just fyi, there are dozens. It’s how many disputes are settled here. By all the evidence, Marielle’s death points to local dispute w/ a direct political opponent ‘n the militia….Temer’s no saint, but to involve him (w/ a local alderwoman) is just conspiracy.

    Putin, right-wing ? NOW, you ARE being naïve…what about the assassination attempts of ex-Russian spy ‘n his daughter in England ? The USSR/KGB way of eliminating enemies. Being educated doesn't necrlly mean acceptance, perhaps tolerance.

    Posted 3 days ago - Link - Report abuse 0
  • DemonTree

    “Temer banned it.”

    You said you're a libertarian; what do you think the law should be?

    University is free in Brazil too, I thought? So why does anyone need a scholarship? And are there no social services for kids thrown out by, or running away from their families, whether transgender or for any other reason? Judging by the number of kids on the street, I guess not.

    Re Dilma, even if she did do more 'creative accounting' than previous presidents, we know that wasn't why she was impeached, it was because they didn't like the way she was handling the economy. Temer admitted as much. I doubt the PT had any better reasons when they tried to impeach FHC.

    “The BF, while put enough food on the table, raised NO ONE “out-of-poverty”.”

    It got people out of extreme poverty, it was the growth of the economy due to the boom in exports that did most to get people out of poverty altogether. And with the recession, they're slipping back into it again, with seemingly no end in sight. I only hope it doesn't last as long as the financial crisis has in Europe, but your government seems to following a similar path to the one that has only perpetuated the sickness here.

    ““may” have been against it, dunno.”

    I very much doubt it. Seeing your antipathy for the UN and it's 'interference' with Brazil, and sympathy for the anti-immigrant crowd in America, it's almost inevitable you would have voted out. Besides which, no one was very well informed here either, because the campaigns were crap, and the leave campaigners told people not to listen to the experts and instead believe whatever they wanted to be true.

    Suppose I'll have to stop being lazy and look up those assassinated Mayors...

    Re Putin, Saudi Arabia recently assassinated a journalist in their own embassy in Turkey. Pinochet ordered the assassination of the former Chilean ambassador in the US, during Operation Condor. You're not going to tell me Pinochet, or the king of SA, were/are communists?

    Posted 3 days ago - Link - Report abuse 0
  • Jack Bauer

    Why have a law ? if lessons are available, the parents should have the right to decide if want their kids attending them, or not.
    “Public” univs are free in Bzl, but there are entry exams…or not, if you’re are poor ? black ? trans-gender ? Social services for those kids DO exist, however not very efficient - besides, many prefer the streets.
    Dilma’s ‘creative accounting’ WAS the “cause” of her impeachment…what motivated Congress was political. Rightly condemned - for the wrong motive ? Temer’s admission is irrelevant to the cause. The PT’s attempts to impeach FHC were only to cause trouble.

    Raising someone “out-of-poverty”, if defined as giving them food, is miles fm actually getting them “out” of poverty…they carry-on living in shitty homes, w/o decent public health svcs or security ; the BF kept them alive, no more.

    The economic boom, exports, were not Lula’s to claim. He passed no laws which contributed to ‘sustainable economic growth’. Of those he did, none were responsible for higher/better employment, salary mass, consumption…or, the virtuous circle.

    “ ‘may’ have been against it, dunno ”…Presuming the UN’s interference takes on different characteristics in each country, and IF I lived in the EU, I might have a different view of them…but I live here, analyze their interference, in Bzl.

    IF I wasn’t who I am, obviously I’d have different views etc…So, if no one was well-informed re Brexit -’n that was in the UK – even a supposedly ‘clarified’ population can be duped. No use comparing ‘ifs and ands.

    Today, if Putin heads Russia ‘n has allowed it to move to the centre, just shows he’s a savvy politician…he wouldn’t have been head of the KGB, if he didn’t believe in communism ; he was forced to, and adapted well to the new reality, but deep down he’s the same old Putin. Like FHC :exiled communist, came back under different circumstances, did what he did…but underneath, still a left-winger.
    Pinochet, right-winger. SA, a very different system, no L or R.

    Posted 3 days ago - Link - Report abuse 0
  • DemonTree

    Well, lessons aren't available anymore. Much like the US where parents could always withdraw their kids from sex-education classes, but now in many areas they've banned the 'education' part completely, with the expected results in teenage pregnancies and STIs.

    “many prefer the streets”

    Social services must be pretty dire if kids prefer the streets. And it's still a mystery what the scholarships are paying for. School supplies, text books? Transport to get there? In England we no longer got a free bus to school after age 16 (and from where I lived there was no practical public transport to the sixth form, either). Do poor children get free school dinners in Brazil, too?

    “Dilma’s ‘creative accounting’ WAS the “cause” of her impeachment”

    I think you're splitting hairs. If the rest of Congress had been happy with the way she was running the country, they would have continued looking the other way.

    Re Lula, putting more money in the hands of the poor does tend to benefit the economy, increase consumption etc, since they usually spend it locally, creating more jobs. Same with increasing the minimum wage, up to a point. Brazil benefited from the export boom, which had more to do with China's economic policies than Brazil's, but previous export booms didn't raise people out of poverty, presumably because the workers never saw much of the profits.

    Putin wasn't head of the KGB; he was made head of the FSB, its successor, by Yeltsin, several years after the end of communism. Putin had previously been a KBG agent, and according to him: “In intelligence at that time, we permitted ourselves to think differently and to say things that few others could permit themselves.” When he became president, he brought back some of the government control/authoritarianism of communist times, but following a right-wing ideology instead. SA is right-wing, like Pinochet, but what was your point in bringing up the Skripals?

    Run out of room to talk about the EU...

    Posted 2 days ago - Link - Report abuse 0
  • Voice

    You two are always running out of space...
    Carry on...

    Posted 2 days ago - Link - Report abuse 0
  • Jack Bauer

    IF G-I lessons are indispensable (which I think they aren't), no doubt they'll eventually be reincorporated in to the curriculum.

    Social svcs : don't think of them as they are in the UK...here, they're 'different'.
    Rgrdng scholarships 'n what they entail, maybe you should ask Haddad...in any case, privileging trans-genders on account of sexual option, is nuts
    Maybe Haddad's way of bringing them to the PT.

    Splitting hairs ??? Nooo...breaking the law is breaking the law...period. Sure Congress could have let her off the hook (as they did Lula in 2007, when the PMDB managed to bury the movement to impeach..) but I am talking of the 'cause' which led to her impeachment... and you carry-on trying to find some excuse to pardon her. Give it up please, there's nothing more to say about it.

    Agree that BF funds being funnelled into the economy as 'consumption' would have a positive effect - to the economy, and to the recipients' stomachs - but to claim it lifted them 'out-of poverty', (and into a higher social class ?) in a 'sustainable' fashion ? Don't think so.

    “workers never saw much of profits”...many Cos, besides paying a 13th salary (obligatory, by law), adhered to profit sharing, (law passed in 2000), but obviously depended on company profitability. Jobs 'n salaries get people 'out-of-poverty'.

    Re Putin : KGB agent for 16 years (6 of which in Dresden); in '89, when the USSR imploded, he was (37 yrs old and) a Colonel in the service...in '94 he went into politics 'n was elected mayor of St. Petersburg. FSB, founded '95, substituted the KGB. In '98, Boris Yeltsin made him head of the FSB... KGB, or FSB, same thing. Re Putin's “we permitted ourselves to think differently...”..how different ? not much. But if you want to believe he's right wing, go ahead. SA, a wahhabist monarchy...L or R not applicable, imo.

    Skripals:.ex-double agent; frowned upon by Russia; poisoned, method usually used by KGB/FSB to eliminate enemies...and what did Scotland Yd conclude ?

    Posted 2 days ago - Link - Report abuse 0
  • DemonTree

    “privileging trans-genders on account of sexual option”

    Well, I agree. If they need help because they are on the streets, or because schools won't let them attend, or whatever other problem it might cause them, they should get help because of that, not simply for being transgender.

    I'm not trying to find an excuse to pardon Dilma, I'm saying Congress did not impeach her because they cared about the law (as if!) It was just politics, same as the PT's attempts.

    “breaking the law is breaking the law”

    What's the penalty for bribing a traffic cop in Brazil?

    Re the BF, studies show it did improve the economy, which means more jobs, which can get people out of poverty or into a higher social class. It wasn't necessarily the recipients who got the jobs or got out of poverty, but someone did.

    What is the point of the 13th salary? Why not just increase the normal pay by the same amount? And maybe if profit sharing was passed earlier then workers would have got more benefit from earlier booms.

    “Jobs 'n salaries get people 'out-of-poverty'.”

    Tell that to all the people in the world who have jobs and still live in poverty. Jobs, salaries, and economic growth are all necessary to get people out of poverty, but they aren't sufficient on their own.

    “KGB, or FSB, same thing”

    Except you don't need to be a committed communist to head up the FSB. And all the evidence points to Putin ordering the Skripals' poisoning, but what has that got to do with him supposedly (still) being a communist?

    Anyway, perhaps it's not important. If we both agree on disliking those forms of government, and wouldn't want our own countries to become more like either of them, then does it matter if they are left, right, or neither? Only in that we could be guarding against the wrong thing, if you believe only left-wing governments become authoritarian, and I think it's only right-wing ones.

    But what exactly do you object to in Russia and SA? I'm curious if it's the same things I do.

    Posted 2 days ago - Link - Report abuse 0
  • Jack Bauer

    Put it this way, Dilma was incompetent as hell, deserved to be kicked out. End. PT's attempts at impeaching FHC had no substance, merely to throw sh*t in the fan. Fine for trying to bribe a cop ? no idea, but think today it might lead to yr arrest.
    Look, I’m not saying the BF was bad, because it wasn’t, but it contributed very little (or nothing) to overall and permanent reduction in poverty.
    13th salary, was a bonus…taxation on it was lower than on one’s regular salary, which reduced govt ‘n corporate costs on payroll - IF ‘ifs ‘n ands’ were pots and pans…they weren’t.
    “Tell that to all the people in the world who have jobs and still live in poverty”…first, I’m not talking about the world, second is it preferable to not have jobs ‘n salaries, but instead, the BF ??? you are arguing against yrself..
    Re Putin : sure, 16 years in the KGB as an agent…and not committed ? I’d loved to have seen how that would turn out. The Skripals were just a reference to what the KGB might do, and Putin’s mindset while he was an agent…nothing more. Why does a country need ideology to get ahead ? it needs a system of government, one that allows freedom and that does not screw its people. Either extreme, once implemented, is authoritarian, but first you have to be able to characterize the country being one thing or the other, or neither…(i.e, the middle ?).
    Have nothing against present-day Russia (other than the still only ‘relative’ freedom) ; my opinion is that Putin, who had to be a committed communist to serve – and survive - 16 yrs in the KGB, adapted himself to a new reality after the USSR ended, but does not act like a communist now, because he’s realized it’s gone (hopefully 4ever), but he’s still in control, in a similar fashion to what he’d be if the USSR still existed…with which, imo, he’d have no problem. Object about SA ? I did not bring it into the discussion – you did – but I think wahhabism goes a bit too far, not to mention the (still) lack of freedom for women.

    Posted 2 days ago - Link - Report abuse 0
  • DemonTree

    “ifs ‘n ands”

    My point was, this law couldn't do much to help people benefit from profits pre-Lula, because it was only passed 3 years before he took over. Maybe it was part of the reason they benefited more afterwards, and that's fair enough.

    “is it preferable to not have jobs ‘n salaries, but instead, the BF”

    No. Why would you even think that? I said jobs were necessary, but not sufficient. Just having a job does not inevitably get you out of poverty, it has to pay enough, and you have to get enough hours. The BF could be a top-up for those who don't get enough pay, or to tide over the unemployed until they find a job.

    “Why does a country need ideology to get ahead ?”

    I don't know, but most people believe in something, and base their system of government on that. Re Russia, you don't have a problem with them invading Ukraine, or Putin murdering dissidents in other countries, and journalists and political rivals in his own? Those things plus the fact that freedom in Russia is reducing, not increasing, as Putin tightens his grip, are what I mostly object to. As for SA, that's much worse - no elections, the royal family run everything so if you're not a member you have no chance of advancing, sharia law complete with beheading for political 'crimes', ridiculously strict religious traditions, and woman literally treated like children, legally. It's the fact it's an absolute monarchy, and the support for tradition, religion and hierarchy that make me think it's right-wing if it's anything. But regardless, I certainly wouldn't want to live there - I'd even prefer Venezuela. While I'm sure you wouldn't go that far, I would think you'd still find plenty to object to?

    Posted 2 days ago - Link - Report abuse 0
  • Jack Bauer

    DT
    Profit sharing: even before regulated, companies I worked for embraced the idea…bonuses could be as much as 5 salaries, as the better the performance, the more generous they'd usually be…but it depended on having a profit…after paying shareholders.

    Me: “is it preferable to not have jobs ‘n salaries, but instead, the BF”;
    You : “No. Why would you even think that? I said jobs were necessary, but not sufficient”….
    Well, in a prosperous economy, having one full-time job should be enough…if not, get a 2nd, part-time…many people do. But if what they earn is insufficient, may I suggest they study, or get a better job ? reason why a “minimum” wage exists…but what do you suggest, in a country where public finances are usually subject to pernicious influences ? where continuity of policy is usually hampered by change of administration ? in other words, government that has not yet realized the people come first.

    When I asked “Why does a country need ideology to get ahead ?”, presume you unstood what I meant : NOT necry…when government promotes ideology, in detriment of competence and/or honesty, it usually ends up derailing the economy, in that it no longer sustains itself…to prosper, an economy needs a free-market, allowing the market forces to interact, without excessive restrictions. Maintaining law ‘n order, allowing people to get on with their lives is not solved through ideology. People need to be able to believe in a better future, the chance to better themselves individually …it’s a simple objective that most people strive for, which has nothing to do with ideology.

    It’s not that I “don’t have a problem w/ Russia invading Ukraine” etc….of course I don’t condone it, but there isn’t enough space on here to list everything…assassinations etc... Reduced freedom as Putin tightens his grip, is his instinct for survival, ingrained in him while in the KGB.
    Re SA, ok, but L or R means nothing to them, just being the absolute authority.
    Prefer VZ ? Careful.....

    Posted 1 day ago - Link - Report abuse 0
  • DemonTree

    “bonuses could be as much as 5 salaries”

    I'm not sure what that means, but it sounds pretty generous? Which workers would get these bonuses?

    “if what they earn is insufficient, may I suggest they study, or get a better job ?”

    That's what I'd suggest to a friend who is unemployed. However, someone has to do those jobs, so if they find a better one it will just pass the problem on to someone else. And it's hard enough to get one job in a recession, let alone two.

    Looking at history, 150 years ago in Britain people used to work 12 hour shifts in factories and down mines, men, women and even children in dangerous conditions, and they still lived in poverty. Things are very different now, and it's not because we work harder than our ancestors, so what changed? Child labour was banned, laws on safety were passed, and workers formed unions and demanded higher pay.

    Brazil can't afford to be as generous as the UK, but they could have eliminated hunger long ago. Like you say, the governments haven't put the people first.

    “NOT necry”

    But it is. How can you have a government without ideology? Those things you mentioned ARE an ideology, tho most of it is a pretty uncontroversial one. There's two aspects to ideology, one is what sort of country you are aiming for, which people will never agree on, and the other is the means to get there, where everyone has their own theory (eg what restrictions are excessive). It becomes a problem when people are so attached to their ideas that they won't admit they are not working.

    Re Russia and SA, I thought maybe you just didn't want to admit that right-wing regimes can be authoritarian (which seems strange to me, seeing all these Islamic regimes and the religious right in America, but you grew up with communism). But maybe growing up in the Americas, you have a different idea of left and right. I would say support for monarchy, religion, and 'traditional' values and hierarchies are all major right-wing characteristics.

    Posted 1 day ago - Link - Report abuse 0
  • Jack Bauer

    DT
    Bonuses for floor workers in industry, not sure (as never was one), but pretty sure not as high as I sometimes got, 18 salaries p/ yr. With tough competition, the quality of one's Commercial/Sales team ‘n the service given was where you made the difference…full ships round-trip, meant big profits. The higher up, the bigger the bonuses.

    In a competitive market, people move on 'n up, and others (usually less qualified) take their place. That’s what I did when I felt I was ready 'n wanted more money. In a recession, it’s obvious things get harder...for most.
    Here, 100 years ago, work conditions weren’t much better….long hours, low wages, no rights…Unions eventually were formed to change that.

    ”…very different now, and it's not because we work harder than our ancestors, so what changed?”…enormous variety of products, competition, specialization, technology, productivity ?

    What I’m saying is that ideology, left or right-wing, is not essential for government to function properly – expertise, competence, common sense 'n honesty are, which are not ideological factors. A government should aim for sustainable prosperity, quality of life for the people etc (where's does 'ideology' come in to that objective ?)…who wouldn't want that ? probably only someone who (for personal gain or group interests) would introduce ideology to influence people...

    ”…people are so attached to their ideas that they won't admit they aren't working.”...that, in itself, has nothing to do with ideology, nor will ideology ‘make’ ideas work. Most politicians preach ideology as a means to attract people, but good ideas are not a privilege of the left or right.

    Both L ‘n R regimes can be authoritarian, but authoritarian regimes don’t necessarily have to be L or R to maintain absolute power.
    Afaic, Islam is a totally different cup of tea…traditionally, a way of life above everything else, with a very conscious and unquestioning respect for authority, but neither L or R as I know it.

    Posted 9 hours ago - Link - Report abuse 0
  • DemonTree

    What does 18 salaries mean? 18 x the minimum wage? And does salary mean monthly, so your bonus was 1.5 x a minimum wage worker's whole annual salary? That seems pretty damn generous, even with Brazil's low minimum wage. And you get a tax break on it too! We have to pay tax on bonuses; you would surely have been higher rate, so 40%, and anyway companies have been stingy since the financial crisis, which happened right after I got my first proper job (but at least I had one).

    Besides, it's the sales people who get the big bonuses, while we have to work overtime to clean up the mess because they told the client that our product can do all kinds of things it can't.

    “enormous variety of products, competition, specialization, technology, productivity ?”

    Definitely, those things were also essential. If a country doesn't generate wealth, then no one can be better off. But productivity gains aren't automatically passed on to the workers. From what I have heard, things were different in the 60s and 70s, before increasing the profits of shareholders became the be-all and end-all for company directors.

    “sustainable prosperity, quality of life for the people etc... who wouldn't want that ?”

    Some leaders don't, or they want other things more: to conquer other countries, stay in power, or just buy a diamond-encrusted Mercedes-Benz. Or they want people to follow their religious laws, or to achieve ethnic homogeneity by murdering a whole race of people. That's extreme, but those are uncontroversial goals. You only have to look at the US to see how much people can disagree on the purpose of government.

    “Both L ‘n R regimes can be authoritarian”

    Yes. And you are part of a minority that often suffers under communism, so not surprising you'd be more afraid of them than of the military. As for the Islamists, I think their beliefs are similar in essence to those of the US religious right, or Brazil's bullets, beef and bibles caucus, but way more extreme.

    Posted 6 hours ago - Link - Report abuse 0
  • Jack Bauer

    DT
    18 salaries means, if I earned $ 10,000/month, then I received $ 180,000 in that year (12 regular salaries, one 13th salary, and 5 salaries as a bonus). Of course we paid tax on the bonus, but better to pay 27,5 % income tax at source, than not receive the other 72,5%..... and even better to get it tax-free, under the counter.

    I don't know what sort of mess your Sales people usually make, but in my line of work, Sales was the driving force behind the business, presuming the other depts (operations, documentation) did nothing to screw that up....like letting the container fall off the ship into the sea, like issuing the documentation with mistakes, causing problems with Customs, local or at destination....there was so much that COULD go wrong, but it was a matter of avoiding it, and damage control when it did.

    Here, where profit-sharing is practised, it's based on yearly productivity.

    “Some leaders don't, or they want other things more”....that's exactly my point....“those” leaders think the people are just a means towards an end (theirs).

    “Yes. And you are part of a minority that often suffers under communism”,...
    Yes, I was part of a minority, that had communism taken over, would no doubt have been screwed, but at the time, we did not know what would happen, so it wasn't a matter of being more afraid of the communists than the military. We went to sleep with Jango in power and woke with the military in power.

    While the US's “religious” right , might go overboard every now and again, I have not seen them promote terrorist attacks (or blow themselves up), aimed randomly at people they don't even know. Afaic, I try not to get involved with fanatics, religious, political or otherwise.

    Posted 4 hours ago - Link - Report abuse 0

Please log in or register (it’s free!) to comment.