MercoPress, en Español

Montevideo, December 17th 2018 - 03:11 UTC

Falklands' Argentine cemetery remains' identification turns into controversy

Wednesday, April 22nd 2015 - 03:18 UTC
Full article 120 comments
According to a piece in La Nación, Argentina claims the UK is deliberately delaying the process of identifying the NN graves at the Darwin cemetery According to a piece in La Nación, Argentina claims the UK is deliberately delaying the process of identifying the NN graves at the Darwin cemetery
But the government of David Cameron immediately replied regretting that Buenos Aires had decided “to politicize a humanitarian matter” But the government of David Cameron immediately replied regretting that Buenos Aires had decided “to politicize a humanitarian matter”
FCO minister Hugo Swire, last year according to La Nacion called on Argentina to contact the British and Falklands governments to implement the identification FCO minister Hugo Swire, last year according to La Nacion called on Argentina to contact the British and Falklands governments to implement the identification
In 2012 César Trejo head of a Relatives of fallen in Malvinas commission admitted the issue was very delicate since not all families agreed with identifying remains    In 2012 César Trejo head of a Relatives of fallen in Malvinas commission admitted the issue was very delicate since not all families agreed with identifying remains

The United Kingdom regretted that Argentina was 'making politics out of a humanitarian issue”, following the claim from the administration of President Cristina Fernandez that UK was delaying the identification process of 123 Argentine soldiers, who died during the 1982 Falklands War and were buried as the Unknown Warriors on the Islands Argentine cemetery.

 The military conflict with United Kingdom after the Argentine military invaded the Falklands in 1982 ended with the transgressors' capitulation and over 900 people dead, including three Islanders. The Argentine cemetery at Darwin has 237 graves, of which 123 remain unidentified.

On Monday Buenos Aires daily La Nación reported citing government sources that London has not replied to a request sent by Argentina five months ago to allow Red Cross and Argentine forensic experts carry out DNA testing on soldiers buried in the Falklands under the caption “Argentine soldier known only to God”. The newspaper added that the process will have to be delayed for at least five more months due to the forthcoming winter in the Southern Hemisphere.

The article from Martin Dinatale, quoting Argentine government sources, underlines that the UK is doing its utmost to delay the arrival of International Red Cross and Argentine forensic experts to the Falklands to begin the task of checking the DNAs of families who lost beloved ones in the war with those of remains in the NN graves.

“This can only lead us to believe that UK is applying delay tactics”, since this means waiting five months before good climate conditions return to the Islands, writes La Nacion quoting its source, adding that the delay can also be attributed to the current political campaign leading to 7 May general election.

Last 2 April during the 32nd anniversary of the war, President Cristina Fernandez in a speech from Ushuaia announced that the collection of DNA samples from next of kin for testing with the graves' NN remains had been completed and only the 'political decision' from the UK was missing to advance in the humanitarian aspect of the issue.

Apparently Argentina six months ago through the International Red Cross presented the request for the forensic experts to travel to the Falklands, but “so far there has been no reply”.

However a Foreign Office spokesperson speaking to La Nación said that “as with the Falkland Islands government, we show our solidarity with the families of those who lost their lives in the Falklands and wish to identify their beloved ones. It's a delicate and complex humanitarian matter which the British government takes seriously”.

“The Argentine government understandably took its time to present the proposal, which is being analyzed by the corresponding parties. The issue can't be rushed since it is important to outline the process in the correct way. We regret that the Argentine government has decided to politicize this humanitarian issue”, concluded the statement.

Last year Foreign Office minister Hugo Swire called on Argentina to contact the UK and Falklands' governments formally to implement the process of identification of NN soldiers' remains. However Argentina argued that since it was a humanitarian issue it was coordinated by the International Red Cross and not directly between London and Buenos Aires.

Nevertheless it should be recalled that when the DNA initiative was first launched by the government of Cristina Fernandez not all families agreed, and the Relatives of the Fallen in Malvinas commission was openly disappointed the announcement was done without previous consultation. (Mercopress 25/04/2012).

“There are families that wish to see the grave of their loved one identified, which is legitimate, but there are also families that express the opposite since they have gone through the mourning process, which is also legitimate”, said at the time César Trejo, a Malvinas veteran and head of a Relatives of the Fallen in Malvinas Commission who claimed represented 550 of the 649 families who lost their beloved in the conflict.

“We must respect all the wishes and spiritual needs of all families that have their sons buried at the Darwin cemetery”, said Trejo. “It is a very delicate, and divisive, situation, since by implementing the rights of one of the families we could be violating the rights of another”.

Finally on 10 April 2012, Red Cross spokesperson Steve Anderson said that the organization was prepared to intercede and mediate “as long as it is requested by all the families and sides involved”. Since ”identifying the remains of the fallen without the consent of their families would mean reopening deep wounds and putting back the clock to very painful times”, according to Anderson.

Top Comments

Disclaimer & comment rules
  • Marcos Alejandro

    “An unknown British sailor has been buried with an Argentine Honour Guard”

    http://en.mercopress.com/2007/03/05/unknown-british-sailor-buried

    Apr 22nd, 2015 - 04:03 am 0
  • Lord Ton

    The FIG have yet to receive a request by the Government of BA. The Government in the UK pass all requests on to the FIG, so it has to be assumed, that no such request has been forwarded by the CFK government, and that this is just more propaganda bullshit.

    Apr 22nd, 2015 - 04:58 am 0
  • Troy Tempest

    @1 “Off-Topic Alejandro”

    Marcos strikes again with another childish distraction

    - best ignored...

    Apr 22nd, 2015 - 05:09 am 0
Read all comments

Commenting for this story is now closed.
If you have a Facebook account, become a fan and comment on our Facebook Page!