MercoPress, en Español

Montevideo, September 26th 2018 - 12:59 UTC

Belize-Guatemala incident reignites standing border dispute; OAS calls for a 'lasting peace'

Monday, April 25th 2016 - 05:30 UTC
Full article 88 comments
Guatemala’s Defense Minister, Mansilla, was photographed on the Sarstoon River on Friday, after Guatemala deployed additional troops to the area Guatemala’s Defense Minister, Mansilla, was photographed on the Sarstoon River on Friday, after Guatemala deployed additional troops to the area
All Belize security forces have been placed on high alert, following a meeting of  Minister of National Security John Saldivar and senior command of forces All Belize security forces have been placed on high alert, following a meeting of Minister of National Security John Saldivar and senior command of forces
Guatemala purports to have repudiated the 1859 Boundary Treaty it had inked with Britain, which shows the boundary line running south of Sarstoon Island. Guatemala purports to have repudiated the 1859 Boundary Treaty it had inked with Britain, which shows the boundary line running south of Sarstoon Island.

The Organization of American States, OAS, has called on the governments of Belize and Guatemala to avoid an escalation of tensions, and renew efforts to establish a lasting peace. The OAS statement follows a previous repudiating “the death of a Guatemalan minor [Julio Alvarado, 13] at the hands of a Belizean patrol”.

 However the latest OAS release did not mention the fact that Guatemala has announced that it has dispatched a further 3,000 troops to its borders with Belize, including its most dangerous shooters — the Kaibiles. The incident occurred in a border disputed area and highly sensitive for both sides.

Likewise Guatemala’s Defense Ministry released photos of its minister patrolling the Sarstoon boundary and publicized its military deployments to the Belize border by posting several photos on social media.

Belize has described the content and tone of a message delivered Wednesday by Guatemala’s president Jimmy Morales as inflammatory, and the widely circulated video, which went viral on social media soon after its release, has prompted widespread adverse reaction from people on both sides of the border.

Guatemala’s Defense Minister, Williams Mansilla, was photographed on the Sarstoon River on Friday, after Guatemala deployed additional troops to that area only a day after Belize opened its Joint Forces Operating Base on the northern bank of the river to police illegal fishing, logging, camping and other such activities in the area.

According to the Government of Belize, the minor who was killed on Wednesday inside the Chiquibul National Park had been shot after the Belize Defense Force, on law enforcement patrol on the Belize side of the border, came under fire. The Belize soldiers responded in self-defense, the Belize Government said.

OAS said its “Office in the Adjacency Zone of Belize and Guatemala will investigate the incident at the request of both governments. Once the investigation is concluded the report with its results will be delivered to both Foreign Ministries for the appropriate actions.”

“This incident reinforces the need to observe the confidence building measures in place, in order to prevent future confrontations or situations that could put at risk the peace and stability in the Adjacency Zone, as well as in the area of the Sarstoon River.”

Guatemala has recently rejected an 11-point proposal for peacekeeping at the Sarstoon River, in the face of escalating tensions over Belize’s use of the river. Belize’s boundary with Guatemala at that point runs at the mid-channel point but Guatemala has taken a hard-line stance that the entire river belongs to it. That country purports to have repudiated the 1859 Boundary Treaty it had inked with Britain, which shows the boundary line running south of Sarstoon Island.

In concluding its release, the OAS General Secretariat said that it “reiterates its recommendation that the two sides carry out the procedures provided for in their respective internal systems as soon as possible, to hold referenda on the decision to submit the territorial controversy to the International Court of Justice, in accordance with the Special Agreement. This is the only viable option to resolve the dispute in a peaceful and permanent way.”

“With the conclusion of the meeting this morning between Minister of National Security Hon. John Saldivar and the senior command of our security forces, all security forces have been placed on high alert and a short term strategy has been devised to deal with further possible incidents along the border areas and in the Sarstoon,” an official National Security release said.

It added that, “The Ministry of National Security… will take any and all actions appropriate to preserve our sovereignty and territorial integrity.”

The US State Department also issued a statement today, referring to Belize’s border as a “disputed area” and omitting to mention that Guatemala has aggressively amassed troops on the border with Belize.

“We are deeply concerned by reports today that a child was killed and two family members injured in the disputed area between Guatemala and Belize known as the Adjacency Zone. We express our deepest condolences to the family.

”We urge calm and restraint by both sides, and we call for a full investigation of the facts surrounding this tragedy.

“Finally, we encourage both countries to cooperate fully with the OAS Adjacency Zone Office and to continue engaging in the confidence building measures agreed upon in 2005. We reiterate our support for both countries to continue efforts to hold referenda on referring the territorial dispute to the International Court of Justice”.

Belize is former British Honduras, a parliamentary democracy and a Commonwealth realm The country is independent since September 1981. A small British force is stationed in the country which has a standing border dispute with neighboring Guatemala since the mid XIXth century. The dispute is under mediation of OAS.

Top Comments

Disclaimer & comment rules
  • Troy Tempest

    “ ... Guatemala deployed additional troops to that area only a day after Belize opened its Joint Forces Operating Base on the northern bank of the river to police illegal fishing, logging, camping and other such activities in the area.”

    Am I to take it that Guatemala objected to Belize policing its own side of the border, stopping logging and poaching of fish, possibly by the Guatemalans?

    Provocative move to break a treaty and claim to the whole river and its resources.

    Apr 25th, 2016 - 06:01 am 0
  • lsolde

    Haven't we heard this sort of thing before?
    Of course, its the tropical version of the mal……something or other myth.

    Apr 25th, 2016 - 08:58 am 0
  • Clyde15

    This seems to have being going on for ever.
    In 1961, my brother's RAF squadron was sent from Gibraltar to the West Indies on detachment to “show the flag”. The Guatemalans were getting uppity with their troops massing on the border. Three aircraft were dispatched to fly low over the border and the Guatemalans quickly went back to their bases.
    In 1972, it happened again. This time the Ark Royal was sent at top speed across the Atlantic and launched two buccaneers in an epic flight before an invasion took place. Like the cavalry they arrived in the nick of time and by their presence thwarted the invasion. Various threats continued requiring Harriers to be flown from the UK as a defence measure resulting in a permanent flight (1417) being located there until 1994.
    Whether or not we now have any obligation to defend Belize, I do not know.

    Apr 25th, 2016 - 09:56 am 0
Read all comments

Commenting for this story is now closed.
If you have a Facebook account, become a fan and comment on our Facebook Page!