MercoPress, en Español

Montevideo, September 29th 2023 - 03:58 UTC



Argentina accused of not defending indigenous groups’ human rights

Thursday, December 2nd 2010 - 20:13 UTC
Full article 15 comments
Formosa province governor Gildo Insfran Formosa province governor Gildo Insfran

Argentina’s Advocate General Office and a humanitarian organization called for the intervention of the Inter American Human Rights Commission, CIDH, to ensure the physical integrity of the indigenous Toba community in the northern province of Formosa following incidents with police forces that left two people killed.

The request was made official and addressed to the CIDH office in Washington, a legal branch of the Organization of American States, OAS, and signed by the Advocate’s Office and the Centre for Legal and Social Studies, CELS.

The presentation requests CIDH to intercede before the Argentine government “to protect the indigenous people and its leaders, suspend all eviction actions and promote an investigation and punish those responsible for the attack” which had such a tragic outcome.

The presentation includes a description of the serious events which took place last week and caused the death of Roberto Lopez, a member of the Toba tribe and a police officer plus twenty people injured some of them seriously.

Clashes broke out when the police tried to dislodge by force a route blocked by Toba pickets who are claiming land in Formosa, north of Argentina and neighbouring with Paraguay.

Last August the humanitarian group CELS sent to different Argentine government offices information on the Toba indigenous in Formosa requesting aid and support from the federal government, but apparently to no avail.

CELS recalls that it made another presentation before CIDH back in 2002 following on similar incidents between police forces and another group of indigenous Toba in Formosa defending what they consider their ancestral lands rights.

Different social, political and human rights groups have accused the Formosa provincial government of having triggered the incidents and police repression in alleged coordination and/or sponsoring by big landowners from the region.

The incidents have put the Formosa governor Gildo Insfran from the ruling Justicialista party in a difficult position following on warnings from the provincial Supreme Justice that the incidents are “institutionally very grave” and has opened an investigation into the claims, while opposition groups are demanding his resignation.

Categories: Politics, Argentina.

Top Comments

Disclaimer & comment rules
  • WestisBest

    Reprehensible, I think we'll pass on Argentine Sovereignty and all it's perks thanks.

    Dec 02nd, 2010 - 11:38 pm 0
  • briton

    When did Argentina ever respect anyones human rights, look at the way they treat the islanders, the british, there own people,
    but then the UN knew that , And Argentina wonders why no one talks to them, orr or interested in them any more, unless you include chavez

    Dec 03rd, 2010 - 12:18 am 0
  • JB

    I am going to write in english as good as i can. sorry in advance for the mistakes.

    I don't understand why all the comments are so agressive, from both sides (arg suppporters and britain supporters). Why can't we share our thoughts with out being so rude? I mean, in most of the articles everything is reduced to the Malvinas/Falkland issue. Can't we at least try to leave that problem aside when we discuss about different topics?

    For instances, yes, Toba have been treated very baddly in the last days, but doesn't mean that Argentina has not the willigness to respect Human Rights, we have always fight against these kind of violations. We are doing our best, perhaps it is not enough, but we keep trying.

    I'm 23, how old are you people?

    Dec 03rd, 2010 - 01:44 am 0
Read all comments

Commenting for this story is now closed.
If you have a Facebook account, become a fan and comment on our Facebook Page!