MercoPress, en Español

Montevideo, May 29th 2023 - 19:49 UTC



UN criticizes as “devastating” Venezuela’s decision to pull out from human rights court

Thursday, July 26th 2012 - 21:17 UTC
Full article 25 comments
“We are leaving the Inter American Human Rights Court out of dignity”, said Chavez “We are leaving the Inter American Human Rights Court out of dignity”, said Chavez

United Nations Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR) said on Thursday that Venezuela's pullout of the Inter-American Court of Human Rights, Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR Court) would be “devastating” for the international organization. Spokesperson Rupert Colville said the move “will be not good for Venezuela either.”

Venezuelan President Hugo Chávez accused the IACHR Court this week of supporting terrorism for its ruling in favour of Raúl Díaz, charged with planting bombs in the Embassy of Spain and the consulate of Colombia in Caracas, and he contended that his country would leave the organization “out of dignity.”

“It is very sad seeing a country leaving the Court,” Colville lamented, adding that the organization “plays a key role in the transition to democracy.”

The IACHR has come under intense criticism from some Latin American leaders that increasingly describe it as a pawn of Washington. Allies of Venezuela including Bolivia, Ecuador and Nicaragua have accused the IACHR of improperly weighing in on disputes still being heard in domestic courts and working to undermine their governments.

“Venezuela is withdrawing from the Inter-American Court of Human Rights, out of dignity, and we accuse them before the world of being unfit to call themselves a human rights group,” Chavez said during a military ceremony.

IAHRC ruled Venezuela had violated the rights of Raul Diaz arguing jail conditions were deplorable. Diaz was sentenced to nine years in prison but fled to the United States after winning a conditional release.

Earlier this year, Chavez tasked a council of state made up of allies to study whether or not Venezuela should remain in the group.

The Costa Rica-based tribunal, part of the Washington-based Organization of American States, or OAS, has heard a series of cases accusing the Chavez government of authoritarianism and rights abuses during his 13-year rule.

Rights groups, including Human Rights Watch, say the OAS body provides crucial protections for citizens in countries with weak judiciaries or a history of authoritarian leaders.

Opposition politicians and activists say Chavez has routinely stamped on rights and harassed opponents during an increasingly autocratic rule.

Chavez, who is leading in polls ahead of a re-election bid on October 7, routinely scoffs at those accusations.

The court's sister organization, the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights, has also been criticized for meddling in the affairs of its member nations. Brazil last year upbraided the group for urging a halt to the construction of a hydroelectric dam along a tributary to the Amazon River.

The OAS in June postponed the thorny issue of reforming the human rights commission for six months, an issue which has the organization divided.


Top Comments

Disclaimer & comment rules
  • BritishguyfromLondon

    We've suspected for years but now we KNOW that Venezuela does not respect human rights.

    Jul 26th, 2012 - 09:37 pm 0
  • JohnN

    With teachers like Cuba, Iran, Russia, Venezuela's Chávez is getting excellent mentoring to isolate itself from any critical look at its human rights abuses. In turn, Chávez teaches Ecuador and Bolivia how to behave in the new axis of back-sliding abuse states.

    Part of the responsibility for Venezuela's criminal state being vested in Chávez lies with Venezuelan voters who return this criminal to power, but having been in power since 1998, so many criteria of Venezuelan society have deteriorated: corruption now worst in Western Hemisphere next to Haiti, violence and culture of violence is extremely poor - and transgressions against human rights are growing. Leaving the IACHR only confirms that Chávez' abusive regime prefers to avoid the glare of international human rights protectors.

    Amnesty International Venezuela:

    Human Rights Watch Venezuela:

    Corruption Perception Index 2011:

    Global Peace Index:

    Wiki on homicides 2010:

    Jul 26th, 2012 - 09:44 pm 0
  • Conor

    Surprised?......... No!

    Jul 26th, 2012 - 09:53 pm 0
Read all comments

Commenting for this story is now closed.
If you have a Facebook account, become a fan and comment on our Facebook Page!