MercoPress, en Español

Montevideo, May 24th 2024 - 01:40 UTC

 

 

Argentina's congress to begin evaluation of Justice Fayt's health condition

Wednesday, May 13th 2015 - 07:21 UTC
Full article 8 comments
With a majority vote from the ruling Victory Front and its allies, the committee headed by Anabel Fernandez Sagasti accepted the impeachment proposal With a majority vote from the ruling Victory Front and its allies, the committee headed by Anabel Fernandez Sagasti accepted the impeachment proposal
Justice Fayt finally did not turn up at the regular Tuesday meetings of the S. Court. Fayt's assistants said he stayed at home due to “a change of plans.” Justice Fayt finally did not turn up at the regular Tuesday meetings of the S. Court. Fayt's assistants said he stayed at home due to “a change of plans.”
”What could account for poor performance of duties is having lost the aptitude he once had and we can’t know (if he still does)” argued Anibal Fernandez ”What could account for poor performance of duties is having lost the aptitude he once had and we can’t know (if he still does)” argued Anibal Fernandez

Argentina's Lower House Impeachment Committee has approved a motion to begin evaluations on the health of Supreme Court Justice Carlos Fayt, in order to determine whether the judge has the physical and mental capacity to continue in his post.

 With a majority vote from the governing Victory Front and its allies, the committee led by lawmaker Anabel Fernandez Sagasti, from Mendoza, accepted the proposal brought forward by current Cabinet chief Aníbel Fernández, during his spell as a senator.

Fayt, 97, has seen his health fiercely questioned in the last few weeks, after it was revealed that the veteran judge was not present for the meeting which led to Ricardo Lorenzetti's re-election at the head of Argentina's highest judicial authority.

Government-led criticisms (including from president Cristina Fernandez) have brought equally strong rebukes from opposition politicians and media, who have defended Fayt, his longstanding academic reputation and reference and his place on the Court.

Amid the institutional crisis affecting the Argentine Supreme Court, Justice Fayt resolved not to attend the usual Tuesday meeting and in doing so he again arose doubts over his health condition.

According to judiciary sources, Fayt finally decided not to go the meeting even though he had planned to do it. Fayt's assistants said the 97-year-old magistrate chose to stay at home due to “a change of plans.”

A Supreme Court spokesperson confirmed Chief Justice Ricardo Lorenzetti and Justices Elena Highton de Nolasco and Juan Carlos Maqueda did attend Tuesday's meeting.

“The Justice will not attend (the meeting) today because no apparent settlement has been reached,” a source close to Fayt said.

Finally Cabinet Chief Anibal Fernández defended the decision by Congress to discuss Justice Fayt’s abilities to remain in his position, saying lawmakers were doing “nothing else” but to comply with the law.

Fayt’s services in the Supreme Court were to be hailed said Fernandez, ”so we are not specifically saying that he had no aptitude; what could account for poor performance of duties is having lost the aptitude he once had and we can’t know (if he still does).”

“We are saying nothing else than what the very own legislation says,” the cabinet chief stated affirming that “nobody has an interest to do wrong to him and much less to seek to sanction Doctor Fayt.” “On the contrary, there is no other way to know what is going on.”

Categories: Politics, Argentina.

Top Comments

Disclaimer & comment rules
  • Conqueror

    And the medical qualifications of argieland's congress are? Let's face it, if they had any, Kirchner, Fernandez, Killed and Timplstiltskin would be in sanatoriums!

    May 13th, 2015 - 09:16 am 0
  • Enrique Massot

    The Argentina Supreme Court re-elected minister Ricardo Lorenzetti as president--eight months before his current term expires.
    In the minutes of the meeting where the re-election was decided, minister Carlos Fayt is mentioned as “present” and also as making a motion together with another minister to propose the Court's vice-president.
    Later, it was revealed that Fayt had not been present in the meeting, but that all the paperwork was brought to his house to be signed.
    Those are enough irregularities that put the Supreme Court in bad light.
    Those who are worried about “corruption” in Argentina should perhaps be worried about this latest incident.

    May 13th, 2015 - 01:24 pm 0
  • chronic

    Justices should resign and allow the appointment of a court that the rotting roadkillians are so deserving of.

    “HAVE YOU PETTED A TROLL TODAY?”

    May 13th, 2015 - 02:44 pm 0
Read all comments

Commenting for this story is now closed.
If you have a Facebook account, become a fan and comment on our Facebook Page!