MercoPress, en Español

Montevideo, February 6th 2023 - 04:07 UTC



Spain accuses Gibraltar before the C 24 of “colonialism by consent”

Wednesday, June 15th 2011 - 21:08 UTC
Full article 12 comments
Juan Pablo de LaIglesias, Spanish ambassador at the UN  Juan Pablo de LaIglesias, Spanish ambassador at the UN

Spain has told the United Nations Committee of 24 (C24) that despite the “impasse afflicting the Brussels process”, Madrid's goodwill allows regional co-operation with Gibraltar and UK to continue under the Tripartite Forum.

But it declared that advances in the Forum “are being hampered by the insistence of the local government of the colony to address aspects related to sovereignty that are the sole responsibility of the United Kingdom and Spain.”

Juan Pablo de Laiglesias, Spain's UN Ambassador, said that differences over sovereignty and jurisdiction should be resolved through bilateral negotiations “as the mandate of the United Nations, inspired by the work of the Special Committee on Decolonisation, has repeatedly pointed out” and warned about what he described as “colonialism by consent”.

He urged the C24 to stick to UN procedures and “not to allow territories to be removed from the relevant UN list using arguments alien to the criteria of this Committee.” He said he was confident that in this way the progress that decolonisation of Gibraltar requires could be achieved.

De Laiglesias was emphatic on distinguishing between decolonisation for territories that only need to show they can self-govern and those where there is a sovereignty dispute.

Where there is no sovereignty dispute the opinion of the population is, he declared, the determining factor in the path to decolonisation.

But he said a case by case review also showed that in certain territories “it is the inhabitants of the territory who, seeing their economic stability guaranteed, give up their political independence. These are cases of 'colonialism by consent' that seek to perpetuate themselves, regardless of the criteria of this committee.”

“This assumption,” he added, “is especially problematic when attempting to maintain the existing situation at the expense of the legitimate rights of a third party, as has been happening in other cases, such as that of Gibraltar, which is the one that interests my country.”

The Ambassador argued that in Gibraltar's case the UN has recognised that “the colonial situation disrupts the unity and territorial integrity of Spain and the Administering Power itself admits that the independence of its colony is not possible against the wishes of Spain.”

He said that these two factors are reason enough to consider the need to adopt a practical approach. “It is not realistic to think that the Government of Spain could ever accept the perpetuation of the present situation in which the administering power and the colony seek to ignore Spain's legitimate right under the Treaty of Utrecht and the doctrine of the United Nations.”

In fact UK was not present because it does not regard the C24 as the place to deal with issues such as Gibraltar's decolonisation.

Categories: Politics, International.

Top Comments

Disclaimer & comment rules
  • briton

    Spain like Argentina will not give up as long as Britain is perceived as weak, perhaps Spain would like to try [an Argentinian movement]
    Or just close the gate again,, bowl movement might seem easy in the short term, but like Argentina the motions just won’t stop lol

    Jun 15th, 2011 - 11:56 pm 0
  • Redhoyt

    “colonialism by consent” - we call that democracy !

    Jun 16th, 2011 - 01:37 am 0
  • kbec

    “What about Ceuta and Melilla?” he was asked. “If you can claim Gibraltar because it's pretty near then surely Morocco has an argument to claim Ceuta and Melilla?”. “The UN states that the people of Ceuta and Melilla have the right to self determination” he replied. “This is international law.

    ”It doesn't however apply to Gibraltar because of the Treaty of Utrecht (er, where we willingly gave Gibraltar away) and the doctrine of the United Nations (er...erm...Self Determination)... er, where's my advisor gone..”

    Jun 16th, 2011 - 02:49 am 0
Read all comments

Commenting for this story is now closed.
If you have a Facebook account, become a fan and comment on our Facebook Page!