MercoPress, en Español

Montevideo, July 1st 2022 - 04:57 UTC



Argentine personalities openly support Falklands’ right to self-determination

Tuesday, February 21st 2012 - 20:34 UTC
Full article 119 comments
Jorge Lanata, Beatriz Sarlo and Fernando Iglesias among the free thinkers who helped elaborate “Malvinas, an alternative view” Jorge Lanata, Beatriz Sarlo and Fernando Iglesias among the free thinkers who helped elaborate “Malvinas, an alternative view”

A group of Argentine writers, historians, constitutional law experts, politicians and journalists will be making a formal presentation in support of the Falkland Islanders right to self-determination. They have also criticized the constant harassment to which Islanders are exposed from the administration of President Cristina Fernandez.

The document, “Malvinas, an alternative view”, to be made public on Wednesday is supported by intellectuals such as Beatriz Sarlo, Juan Jose Sebreli, Santiago Kovadloff, Rafael Filippelli, Emilio de Ipola, Vicente Palermo, Marcos Novaro and Eduardo Antón; journalists Jorge Lanata, Gustavo Noriega and Pepe Eliaschev; historians Luis Alberto Romero and Hilda Sábato; constitutional experts Daniel Sabsay, Roberto Gargarella and José Miguel Onaindia, plus former lawmaker Fernando Iglesias.

“Malvinas, an alternative view”, signed by the above renowned 17 personalities emphasize that respect for the interests and opinions of the Falkland Islanders, ‘under British sovereignty since 1833’ is the backbone of the document’s foundation.

The group was created following on informal contacts among its members after several of them participated in public debates ahead of the thirtieth anniversary of the beginning of the Malvinas conflict (2 April 1982) and openly question the official Argentine government position.

The most controversial opinion was that from historian Luis Romero who published an opinion column in La Nacion under the heading of “Are the Malvinas really ours?”

In the column Romero basically argues there will be no Argentine solution to the Malvinas question until the Islanders want to become Argentines and voluntarily join as citizens of the new State.

The British government historically has supported the Islanders right to self-determination and to remain British as long as they so wish and thus rejects any Argentine suggestion of holding sovereignty talks.

Argentina on the contrary argues that according to the UN Charter the principle of self determination must be applied to an ethnic group over its territory of belonging and not over spaces illegally occupied by a transplanted population.

In support of Argentina’s position the C-24 or UN Decolonization Committee has called on the UK to sit and dialogue on the Falklands/Malvinas sovereignty and lately has managed the support from Mercosur and some Caribbean countries which bar Falklands’ flagged vessels from their ports.

Top Comments

Disclaimer & comment rules
  • GreekYoghurt

    Gosh, these intellectuals are endangering themselves. I'd be worried about a knock on the door from Mao's Red Guards for being so anti-Maoist, sorry, anti-Kerchnerist. Either way, the Kirchner Nationalist Youth isn't going to be happy.

    Send the Falkland Islanders to the C24, it's their territory to discuss. If the C24 wants to talk to someone about independence, then talk to them, we're not putting up hurdles.

    Feb 21st, 2012 - 08:44 pm 0
  • A.J.Rimmer

    Nice to see that there are intellectuals in Argentina, and even better, they have something not commonly found over there.

    Can anyone guess what that is??

    Ans: Independent thought!!!!

    Feb 21st, 2012 - 08:46 pm 0
  • The Falklands are British

    Oh that is just beautiful!

    Okay Yuleno, Marcos, Dreyfoss, Flippo, Malen and company. Let's hear from you. Tell us why this group has no credibility. Tell us why this group is wrong. Tell us that this group is actually paid by the UK. LOL! Oh please tell us!

    I think even the most fanatical of you will agree that we should dispense with the Spanish proficiency tests this time shall we? That's always your solution previously when someone claiming to be Argentine speaks against the Malvinistas. You ask them to write a few lines of Spanish and when they do you claim their grammar was poor so they are therefore English.

    Ha ha ha!

    Feb 21st, 2012 - 08:47 pm 0
Read all comments

Commenting for this story is now closed.
If you have a Facebook account, become a fan and comment on our Facebook Page!