MercoPress, en Español

Montevideo, September 27th 2023 - 05:05 UTC



Uruguayan government takes over bankrupt airline from private investors

Wednesday, June 20th 2012 - 06:37 UTC
Full article 2 comments
Pluna’s former CEO, Matías Campiani only has financial expertise, “not a clue about air industry” Pluna’s former CEO, Matías Campiani only has financial expertise, “not a clue about air industry”

The Uruguayan government has reassumed control of Pluna, the nation's flag carrier after the airline’s controlling shareholder Leadgate announced that it will withdrawal from the ownership structure of the company.

After several weeks of growing tensions between the Uruguayan government and Leadgate over the urgent need to recapitalise the Montevideo-based airline, Pluna CEO Matias Campiani finally announced his resignation last Friday after it became clear that Leadgate would not inject further funds into the company.

President Jose Mujica said that “the problem will be solved” and guaranteed the jobs of the company and the Minister of Transport Enrique Pintado pressed by the media said he could not reveal any details about possible interested parties.

However the opposition has announced it wants a full investigation into the whole process of handing the country’s airline to a group which consistently did not abide by the clauses of the contract, and on several occasion the government was warned about the “improvisation” of the whole privatization project and Campiani’s total lack of experience in the air industry.

“We have been warning for the last three years and now we are saddled with a bankrupt airline, a 300 million dollars debt of unpaid aircraft, over 20 million dollars in fuel from the government’s oil and gas company. It’s a huge scandal which undoubtedly has links to government officials and some local banks” said Senator Carlos Moreira.

Pluna Ente Autonomo, the autonomous state body that manages the government's 25% stake in the airline, confirmed the appointment of former CFO Sebastian Hirsch as Pluna's new interim CEO on Monday in an attempt to assure a smooth transition for the airline.

While Pluna was unavailable for comment, a source at the Uruguayan ministry of Transport confirms that Leadgate transferred its 75% stake to the Uruguayan Stock Exchange, which will “act as fiduciary” until the government determines a game plan.

Leadgate's departure took place after the government agreed to sign a contract under which “both sides renounce [plans] to pursue any legal processes against each other”.

The ministerial source quantifies the immediate recapitalisation needs as being “in the range of 30 to 35 million dollars,” while the total debt load has reached “around 300 million dollars.” Most of the financing for the airline's 13 Bombardier CRJ900s, which were acquired by Pluna under Leadgate's management, has been guaranteed directly by the Uruguayan state, while Export Canada provided guarantees for Pluna's aircraft purchases in 2010 and 2011 that were no longer covered by the Uruguayan state.

The Canadian airline holding company Chorus, which owns up to a 35% stake in Leadgate as well as Jazz, has the rights to acquire the remaining Leadgate shares. If this occurred, the holding company would have 30 days to reverse the decision to exit the stake in Pluna.

However, Chorus has been quoted saying that it has “no intention to invest additional funds,” according to local Canadian reports.

The source at the Uruguayan ministry of transport says, that it will “respect Jazz' [Chorus'] 30 day exclusivity period” to acquire the share package before beginning negotiations with other potential investors.

Uruguayan sources familiar with the process say that the government has contacted both Spain's Air Europa and Argentina's Buquebus, which owns Uruguayan ATR operator BQB Air. However, Air Europa denies having any interest in Pluna, leaving Buquebus-BQB, which has an excellent relationship with the Uruguayan government according to reports, as a potential bidder for the Leadgate package.

A senior source at Buequebus' Buenos Aires headquarters expresses doubts that the carrier's owner Juan Carlos Lopez Mena “would want to pour 30 million dollars into a loss-making carrier and shoulder a more than 200 dollars million share in Pluna's debt load only to acquire an airline in a country in which he already runs an airline.”

However, Lopez Mena might want to help the government as his ferry and Montevideo port terminal concessions have proven vastly profitable. He has also repeatedly tried to become a major player in the airline market in the southern cone with several failed bids for Aerolineas Argentineas.

Another interested party could be one of the collaterals of another rich Argentine entrepreneur Eduardo Eneurkian who already manages Uruguay’s main airport Carrasco and has control over Aeropuertos 2000 which manages most of Argentina’s air terminals.

Categories: Economy, Politics, Uruguay.

Top Comments

Disclaimer & comment rules
  • ChrisR

    There is another solution.

    Government figures state Pluna's debts as being US$ 301.1 million, while the assets are stated as US$ 290 million.

    If the asset price can be realised (and without knowing the facts that is a BIG if) then the US4 11.1 million could be written off.

    Who, in their right mind wants to take on this operation, forced to use ANCAP fuel which is 10% more epensive than the regional mean and a WHOPPING 40% more expensive than the Argentine Government charge their carrier who are in direct competion with Pluna for regional traffic?

    And WHY, with a population of just 4.5 million, many of who will never fly in an airplane in their life, does Uruguay NEED a flag carrier?

    The minister was surprised when the shit hit the fan last week. Been keeping his eye on the ball then?

    Before ANY USD 35 M underwrite is given to any organisation, the Governmant should address these concerns first.

    Jun 20th, 2012 - 07:43 pm 0
  • Self Determination

    Time for the FIG to lease one of the planes ,in return for daily flights,if required, to Montevideo .It makes economic sense for both countries.

    Jun 21st, 2012 - 04:45 pm 0
Read all comments

Commenting for this story is now closed.
If you have a Facebook account, become a fan and comment on our Facebook Page!