MercoPress. South Atlantic News Agency

• 

  ChrisR

  Meddling with Mr. Market will end in tears sooner or later.
  
  You cannot expect these price manipulations to have any serious effect on growth: all that is happening is the forward buying of expected demand.
  
  This demand will stop dead when the prices do go up.
  
  Cash for clunkers, anybody remember that?

  Jul 02nd, 2012 - 05:32 pm - Link - Report abuse 0
  -+

• 

  rnbgr

  It's a short term boost to consumption for sure, a large number of countries used These type of incentives in 2008/2009. Brazil will most likely try limit it to domestically produced items. When the US tried this in 2009 with the “cash for clunkers” they ran into WTO complaints from foriegn trade partners and had to open up to all car suppliers so domestic suppliers only got a partial benefit and the drop- off in demand was steep when the program ended. Russia was able to keep the program limited to domestic cars and it did definitely help Domestic suppliers keep afloat.

  Jul 03rd, 2012 - 12:22 am - Link - Report abuse 0
  -+

• 

  Fido Dido

  Cash for clunkers in the US was indirect “sponsored” by the Chinese who are a major importer of scrap metal from the US. yes, you read that well, that's one of the major exports of the US. The good old Manufacturing base in the US is close to zero. Cash for clunkers was a joke and it totally failed as predicted by many critics. Anyone who believed that GM (include Ford who got saved indirectly bailout money by saving Delphi auto parts who are connected to GM) is out of the woods, should do it's homework again, because it isn't plus they never paid back the auto bailout of 2008.
  
  This is not a cash for clunkers in Brazil, though a similar scheme exist for the lower class ins some states (if you get and pay electricity through the legal channel, you can get for your old refridgerator a new one, to lower your electricity bill, all sponsored by state with local government). Though Brazil's has a rising middle class (from c to b) there are still to many people in class c and d who need and want to buy their first or new refrigerator(s), washing machine(s) and other household appliance. They are produced in Brazil and a tax cut for those industries who will be forced to pass it to consumers is a welcome gift for those people or for the people in class a and b who want a new one or second/third refrigerator, washing machine and other household appliances.
  
  Brazil> Stimulus packages to boost local industries.
  Europe,USA> stimulus packages to save the (zombie) banks (yes, they're dead, no what you do) while the rest gets austerity measures, plus being lectured through all business channels and magazines that it's good because if we don't save the (zombie) banks who gambled and lost, we're all going to die.

  Jul 03rd, 2012 - 04:44 am - Link - Report abuse 0
  -+

Commenting for this story is now closed.
If you have a Facebook account, become a fan and comment on our Facebook Page!