MercoPress, en Español

Montevideo, December 5th 2021 - 07:42 UTC



Court lifts recess: Cristina Fernandez resumes battle with Clarin and farmers

Saturday, January 5th 2013 - 06:06 UTC
Full article 32 comments
The Palermo grounds in Buenos Aires famous for its agro-shows dating back over a century The Palermo grounds in Buenos Aires famous for its agro-shows dating back over a century

Argentina’s Civil and Commercial Court decided to lift the January judicial recess as requested by the administration of President Cristina Fernandez and also granted the cautionary measure appeal to the Argentine Rural Society (SRA) that blocks the presidential decree over the taking over of La Rural grounds in Palermo neighbourhood.

After an intense debate, court members Francisco de las Carreras, Ricardo Guarinoni and Graciela Medina decided to lift the traditional Judicial recess held in January, as they approved the measure presented by the SRA last Wednesday.

Simultaneously, the court accepted the Government's request to set “celerity” to the treatment of the Media Law, which means that those controversial articles (45 and 161) that hinder its application may be declared constitutional and thus the Clarin group could be forced to divest from all those licences above a cap established by the bill.

Last December 14, Judge Horacio Alfonso had ruled that the questioned articles were constitutional and ordered to rule out the injunction presented by the Clarín Group, but the Civil Court ordered instead the extension of the injunction after Alfonso's ruling was appealed.

Last week the Argentine Supreme Court said that until the Civil and Commercial Court rules on the matter, the Clarin group injunction stands.

The Cristina Fernandez administration made a dual presentation, one by cabinet chief Manuel Abal Median and another by the Audiovisual Communications regulator, Afcsa, headed by Martin Sabbatella.

In the case of the Palermo grounds famous for the annual agro-show, the ruling suspends the eviction on 20 January established by a decree signed by Cristina Fernandez, and there can be no innovation in the matter until the validity of the expropriation decree is decided.

SRA argued that decree 2552 was unconstitutional because there was no expropriation involved and the government must first inform the courts of its intention.

The decree simply declared the annulment of the Palermo grounds sale which took place in 1991 under the government of President Carlos Menem.

Categories: Politics, Argentina.

Top Comments

Disclaimer & comment rules
  • TipsyThink

    CFK should battle with sóme farmérs and Clárins.

    Jan 05th, 2013 - 10:00 am 0
  • reality check

    Eviction by decree! and they call themselfs a democracy. What sort of a democracy rules by decree? It's a new one on me, someone from Argentine care to explain, in words of one syllable please!

    If she takes the farmers on, she will lose, no doubt of that. Somewhere near 50% of her income comes from Agricultural Exports, Soy, Wheat, Corn, Vegetable, cattle etc. Who I wonder? does she think produces these items?
    YPF, what is she going to do? Nationalise the Agricultural Industry.


    Jan 05th, 2013 - 01:26 pm 0
  • GeoffWard2

    She may well be thinking of nationalising the agricultural industries and lands of Argentina. The Russians did this and the Cubans (and probably much of China in The Great Leap Forward), so she may favour this approach.
    Trouble is, much of this prime land has been sold to foreigners, especially the Chinese, using Argentinian front-men.
    The Chinese may not be well pleased that their land has been appropriated, and may not be as passive as the Spanish over Repsol.

    Jan 05th, 2013 - 01:48 pm 0
Read all comments

Commenting for this story is now closed.
If you have a Facebook account, become a fan and comment on our Facebook Page!