MercoPress, en Español

Montevideo, September 29th 2023 - 01:28 UTC



Afghanistan: Western armies always lose guerilla wars in the “Third World,” but it never really matters.

Monday, August 16th 2021 - 06:45 UTC
Full article 3 comments
The final weeks in Vietnam before the helicopters started plucking Americans from the U.S. embassy roof in Saigon in 1975. The final weeks in Vietnam before the helicopters started plucking Americans from the U.S. embassy roof in Saigon in 1975.

By Gwynne Dyer - “I will never kneel before such a destructive force (as the Taliban),” declared Ashraf Ghani, the ex-president of Afghanistan before fleeing. “We will either sit knee-to-knee for real negotiations at the table or break their knees on the battlefield.” Good luck with that, Ashraf.

General Sami Sadat, still was in Helmand province and wrote at that time something equally confident, but warned that the safety of the world is at stake: “This will increase the hope for small extremist groups to mobilize in the cities of Europe and America, and will have a devastating effect on global security.”

And how did it all come to this?

Ashraf Ghani pointed out that it is obviously America’s fault. “The reason for our current situation is that the (U.S. decision to withdraw) was taken abruptly,” he told a fleeing parliament in Kabul just two weeks ago.

Well, fair enough. U.S forces have been in Afghanistan for a bare 20 years and the treacherous cowards are already quitting. Donald Trump signed a treaty with the Taliban 18 months ago promising that all U.S. troops would leave Afghanistan by the 1st of May this year. Short notice indeed.

In April Joe Biden unilaterally postponed the departure date to Sept. 11, 2021, whereupon the Taliban started shooting at the foreign troops again.

Then Biden changed the date again, to Aug. 31, a whole 11 days earlier. How abrupt is that? No wonder Ashraf Ghani feels betrayed.

I’m tempted to go back into the archives and find similar brave declarations of imminent victory by South Vietnamese generals (followed by similar predictions of global disaster if they are abandoned) in the final weeks before the helicopters started plucking Americans from the U.S. embassy roof in Saigon in 1975.

But it’s a nice day and I can’t be bothered.

President Ghani, General Sadat and all their friends are reading from the same old script, just 46 years later, and once that final scene has played out in Kabul they’ll go and live in the United States. (Don’t worry. They’ve saved up enough money.)

The only real surprise here is how thoroughly Western armed forces managed to forget their own history.

I’m not talking about the old history, when three invasions of Afghanistan at the height of British imperial power (1839–42; 1878–80; 1919) all failed to achieve their objectives.

I’m not even talking about the Soviet occupation of Afghanistan in 1979-89, when the United States helped the Taliban and similar Islamist groups to do to the Russians exactly what the Taliban have now done to the Americans themselves.

The problem there was that Americans did not see Russians as Western, although viewed from a low orbit they are virtually identical.

U.S. generals therefore believed that some essential difference between the two armies protected American troops from the fate of the Russians.

Never mind all that. The really unpardonable mistake was forgetting all the lessons Western armies had learned from a dozen lost guerilla wars in former colonies between 1954 and 1975.

France in Algeria and Indochina, Britain in Kenya, Cyprus and Aden, Portugal in Angola and Mozambique, the proxy wars in Rhodesia and South-West Africa (as they were then known), and the United States again in Indochina.

All the wars were lost, and yet the defeated imperial powers didn’t really lose anything except face.

Western armies really did learn the lessons of those defeats. As a young man in the 1970s I taught military history and strategy in the Canadian Forces Staff College and then at Britain’s Royal Military Academy at Sandhurst. The doctrine I taught was a) Western armies always lose guerilla wars in the “Third World,” and b) it never really matters.

The Western armies lose no matter how big and well-equipped they are because the insurgents are fighting on home ground. They can’t quit and go home because they already are home. Your side can always quit and go home, and sooner or later your own public will demand that they do. So you are bound to lose eventually, even if you win all the battles.

But losing doesn’t really matter, because the insurgents are always first and foremost nationalists.

They may have picked up bits of some grand ideology to make them feel that ‘history’ is on their side — Marxism or Islamism or whatever — but all they really want is for you to go home so they can run their own show. They won’t actually follow you home.

By 1975 this hard-earned wisdom was official doctrine in almost every army in the Western world, but military generations are short.

A typical military career is only 25 years, so by 2001 nobody remembered it. Their successors had to start learning it again the hard way. Maybe by now they have.

Categories: Politics, International.

Top Comments

Disclaimer & comment rules
  • Baxter

    Interesting . But the author seems to have forgotten two victories by the British in ex-colonies . Malaya -1958/1968 - which was an outstanding victory over the communists . And Cyprus where Greece was unable to control the island . EOKA was soundly defeated . I am particularly surprised by his ignorance on Malaya - a brilliant campaign .

    Aug 16th, 2021 - 01:32 pm 0
  • Don Alberto

    You have a point there, Baxter, but the UK only wonin the short run in Malaya - today Malaya is neither a UK BOT or colony.

    Aug 16th, 2021 - 08:31 pm 0
  • Baxter

    Don Alberto . You are right , up to a point ! After the defeat of the terrrorists Malaya , now Malayasia , gained independence .

    Aug 16th, 2021 - 09:11 pm 0
Read all comments

Commenting for this story is now closed.
If you have a Facebook account, become a fan and comment on our Facebook Page!