MercoPress, en Español

Montevideo, June 2nd 2023 - 21:14 UTC



Lula da Silva’s 8 years marked by corruption and crime, says a Wikileak cable

Wednesday, December 1st 2010 - 22:14 UTC
Full article 3 comments
The Brazilian government has been unable to address public opinion’s main concern, crime The Brazilian government has been unable to address public opinion’s main concern, crime

Brazilian president Lula da Silva concludes his eight years in office with a performance marked by open corruption “among his closest political allies”, with a “plague” of vote-buying in Congress and the ruling party, and without having given a reply to the issue of crime.

This is basically the US embassy evaluation of Lula da Silva’s administration which was reported by US ambassador Clifford Sobel in one of the many cables exposed by Wikileaks.

“The main public opinion concern, crime and public security, have not improved during the administration of President Lula da Silva”, says Sobel in a cable sent from the embassy in Brasilia to the State Department.

The document mentions the several corruption scandals that have occurred under President Lula da Silva. “The Lula administration has been affected by a serious political crisis”, reads the cable adding that “vote-buying and influence peddling” have become a “plague for certain elements of Lula’s Workers party”.

Anyhow Sobbel clearly points out that the “personal popularity of the president did not suffer even after many of his closest associates were caught red-handed in corruption practices”.

The telegram was part of background information sent by the embassy in March 2008 in anticipation of Defence minister Nelson Jobim visit to Washington. US policy objectives at the time were to build closer links with Brazil offering military cooperation agreements and collaboration in guaranteeing ‘certain stability’ in Latin America.

The document also suggests that the successful food basket program, Bolsa Familia, distributed among millions of poor in Brazil had been a big help for the re-election of Lula da Silva in 2006.

“President Lula da Silva was elected in 2002 partly because of his promise to promote an ambitious social agenda including generous handouts to the millions of poor. Given the strong popularity feedback of these measures, Lula da Silva was re-elected in 2006, even when support among middle classes diminished”.

Other cables describe the Brazilian “traditional paranoia” in protecting the Amazon basin “sovereignty” from foreign involvement. Similarly Brazil’s insistence in having “independence” in arms manufacturing and establishing military cooperation agreements with countries willing to transfer technology.

Ambassador Sobel points out that (former) Planning Minister Roberto Mangabeira Unger “gives more importance to ‘independence’ than to military capacity or the efficient use of resources”.

The comments refer to the National Defence Plan, PND, launched by President Lula da Silva investing billions to upgrade Brazilian forces and re-launch a defence industry. To that effect the announced construction of a nuclear powered submersible by the Brazilian navy in association with France is described as “a white elephant politically popular”.

Finally ambassador Sobel criticizes the Brazilian media coverage of PND which was lacking any serious analysis: “maybe the most significant comment on Brazil’s defence strategy is precisely the lack of any comments”, simply based on government releases.

Categories: Politics, Brazil, United States.

Top Comments

Disclaimer & comment rules
  • xbarilox

    “Lula da Silva’s 8 years marked by corruption and crime, says a Wikileak cable” WRONG! Says the USA! This is what those scumbags think
    about South America. It's funny that countries like Chile, Uruguay, Peru, Colombia, feel so happy thinking that the U.S are friends. haha Mrs. Hillary has said that Berlusconi is USA's best friend.

    Dec 01st, 2010 - 10:55 pm 0
  • Fido Dido

    only dummies think that the US is their “true” friend.
    The reality is, the US has no friends, only Allies..(Al LIES)

    Dec 02nd, 2010 - 03:19 am 0
  • NicoDin

    ”only Allies..(Al LIES)”
    Ehem... Only Interest if you make them make a lot of money you are the best in the world else well you know how this works.

    Dec 02nd, 2010 - 07:45 am 0
Read all comments

Commenting for this story is now closed.
If you have a Facebook account, become a fan and comment on our Facebook Page!